| YEAR | PAST MASTER | YEAR | PAST MASTER |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1852-53 | Chas. E. Blumenthal | 1854 | George Z. Bretz |
| 1855 | Herman M. Johnson | 1856 | Otis F. Tiffany |
| 1857 | William D. Skiles | 1858 | John Hyer |
| 1859 | John Campbell | 1860 | George Weise |
| 1861 | William H. Wetzel | 1862-65 | Jos. W. Patton |
| 1866-67 | Martin C. Herman | 1868 | Edgar Lee |
| 1869 | Thomas Dougherty | 1870 | Samuel R. Claudy |
| 1871 | Abner K. Rheem | 1872 | L. Thomas Greenfield |
| 1873 | J. Marion Weakley | 1874 | W. Blair McCommon |
| 1875-76 | Charles H. Mullin | 1877 | John R. Miller |
| 1878 | Wilbur F. Horn | 1879 | Benjamin K. Spangler |
| 1880-81 | John G. Bobb | 1882 | John M. Wallace |
| 1883 | W. James Dale | 1884 | William F. Riley |
| 1885 | Frederick C. Kramer | 1886-87 | Charles W. Storhm |
| 1888-89 | John A. Means | 1890 | Charles D. Marquette |
| 1891 | Harry G. Beetem | 1892 | D. Edward Brindle |
| 1893 | Wm. M. Handerson, Jr. | 1894 | William R. Baillie |
| 1895 | John L. Henry | 1896 | William R. Claudy |
| 1897 | John A. Senseman | 1898 | Edward J. Wilks |
| 1899 | William A. Kamarer | 1900 | Louis C. Lesher |
| 1901 | Otis F. Connelly | 1902 | John M. Rhey |
| 1903 | Irvin E. Greenwood | 1904 | W. Abner Wetzel |
| 1905 | Elmer G. Jacoby | 1906 | Melvin L. Dunkleberger |
| 1907 | E. Mode Vale | 1908 | John A. Schatz |
| 1909 | William H. Cornman | 1910 | John W. Andrews |
| 1911 | Andrew G. Miller | 1912 | Charles W. Long |
| 1913 | Jasper Alexander | 1914 | Samuel Stuart |
| 1915 | George R. Traxler | 1916 | Tolbert J. Scholl |
| 1917 | Robert W. Peffer | 1918 | Albert M. Wise |
| 1919 | Ira F. Zeigler | 1920 | Robert E. Lininger |
| 1921 | D. Wm. Van Camp | 1922 | T. Howard Uhland |
| 1923 | John A. Ruggles | 1924 | Albert Watson |
| 1925 | Clayton I. Stitzel | 1926 | Val D. Sheafer |
| 1927 | Lloyd B. Ganser | 1928 | Harry B. Sipe |
| 1929 | William G. Snyder, Sr. | 1930 | Luther F. Brame |
| 1931 | Lawrence J. Strickler | 1932 | William G. Snyder, Jr. |
| 1933-34 | J. Vernon Hertzler | 1935 | Erford E. Buckley |
| 1936 | A. Frank Hair | 1937 | Paul E. Wise |
| 1938 | George B. Zug | 1939 | Paul I. Drawbaugh |
| 1940 | Roy E. Hoffman | 1941 | Lee D. Gabler |
| 1942 | Joseph L. Kramer | 1943 | Herbert L. Lear |
| 1944 | Richard H. Zeigler | 1945 | John Palmer, Jr. |
| 1946 | J.E. Kenneth Stephens | 1947 | Ralph L. Bretz |
| 1948 | Mark H. Knouse | 1949 | Walter J. Garver |
| 1950 | Leon W. McGinnes | 1951 | Howard W. Sowers, Jr. |
| 1952 | Walter J. McBride | 1953 | Alvin E. Eby |
| 1954 | John W. McGowan | 1955 | Vaughn C. King |
| 1956 | J. Fredrick Bistline | 1957 | J. Merle Gillaugh |
| 1958 | Lester A. Kern, PDDGM | 1959 | Richard P. Warren |
| 1960 | Paul L. Strickler | 1961 | Daniel D. Eckenrode |
| 1962 | Charles E. Lear | 1963 | R. Edward Bixler |
| 1964 | Emmett L. Shulenberger | 1965 | Peter Pavlik |
| 1966 | Edward S. Calaman | 1967 | Robert M. Finkey, Sr. |
| 1968 | W. Carl Sheaffer | 1969 | William H. Bixler, Sr. |
| 1970 | Joseph E. Grabey | 1971 | Hoke F. Gleim |
| 1972 | Everett L. Swigert | 1973 | David G. Arnold |
| 1974 | Eugene E. Stout | 1975 | James S. Hostetter |
| 1976 | John H. Sherman, Jr. | 1977 | *Orville C. Russell, Jr. |
| 1978 | Thomas W. Lindsay | 1979 | Joseph B. Knouse |
| 1980 | James R. Humer, Jr. | 1981 | Anselm S. Wurfl |
| 1982 | Jem G. Hockenberry | 1983 | G. Michael Turley |
| 1984 | Dennis E. Yeingst | 1985 | A. Lindsay Rowland |
| 1986 | Edward D. Belden | 1987 | Roger C. Spitz, Sr. |
| 1988 | Jeffrey L. Heishman | 1989 | Glen R. Grell |
| 1990 | Andrew S. Zenuch | 1991 | J. Wesley Bower |
| 1992 | C. Leroy Brenneman, Jr. | 1993 | William C. White |
| 1994 | Lewis E. Burgett | 1995 | Lewis E. Burgett |
| 1996 | James R. Humer, Jr. | 1997 | Scott G. Miller |
| 1998 | Kenneth E. Boyer | 1999 | William C. Vohs |
| 2000 | Lester W. Reeder, Jr | 2001 | Glenn H. Bowser |
| 2002 | Chester G. Raudabaugh | 2003 | Scott G. Miller |
| 2004 | James E. Lesher | 2005 | Richard G. Sebring |
| 2006-07 | James R. Humer | 2008 | J. David McKibben |
| 2009 | Michael T. Govora, Jr. | 2010 | Kenneth W. Womack |
| 2011 | John E. Delack | 2012 | Brett R. Otto |
| 2013 | Brent A. Sailhammer | 2014 | Kenneth W. Womack |
| 2015 | Allen J. Light | 2016 | William R. Bunt |
